Two years after leaving her Amish community, Hannah finds herself returning to help her sister who is suffering from a mental condition and facing the same problems she left, including her father's disapproval and her former fiancé.
Lena Kauffman, an Old Order Amish schoolteacher, has been friends with school board member Grey Graber for most of her life, but when her teaching methods come under scrutiny and he experiences a family tragedy, their relationship becomes strained.